why do shield volcanoes have weak eruptions

tdvg authors

4 min read

·

06-03-2025

29

0

Share

Shield volcanoes, those gently sloping giants that dominate landscapes like Hawaii and Iceland, are renowned for their effusive eruptions – characterized by relatively gentle outpourings of lava, as opposed to explosive blasts. But why is this the case? This article explores the geological factors behind shield volcano's less violent eruptions, drawing upon research from ScienceDirect and expanding on the underlying principles.

The Key Factor: Basaltic Magma

The fundamental reason for the gentler nature of shield volcano eruptions lies in the composition of their magma: basalt. Basaltic magma is significantly different from the magmas that fuel explosive volcanoes like stratovolcanoes. Let's delve into the critical properties that differentiate them:

1. Low Viscosity: As explained in numerous studies on ScienceDirect, including work by [cite relevant ScienceDirect article on basaltic magma viscosity here, e.g., "Title of Article" by Author et al., Year], basaltic magma has a low viscosity. Think of viscosity as a measure of a liquid's resistance to flow. Honey is highly viscous; water is low viscosity. Basaltic magma, being less viscous, flows more easily. This readily flowing nature allows gases dissolved within the magma to escape relatively easily, preventing a build-up of pressure.

Example: Imagine trying to squeeze toothpaste (high viscosity) versus water (low viscosity) out of a tube. The toothpaste requires more force, potentially bursting the tube if enough pressure builds. The water, however, flows easily. This analogy perfectly illustrates the difference in eruptive styles.

2. Low Silica Content: Basaltic magmas are silica-poor. Silica, a major component of many magmas, increases viscosity. Lower silica content contributes to the low viscosity of basaltic magma. This is well-documented in volcanological literature readily available on platforms like ScienceDirect. [cite relevant ScienceDirect article on silica content and viscosity here, e.g., "Title of Article" by Author et al., Year]. The lower silica content means the magma is less prone to forming a sticky, plug-like consistency that traps gases.

3. Dissolved Gas Content: While basaltic magmas do contain dissolved gases (primarily water vapor and carbon dioxide), the low viscosity allows these gases to escape gradually as the magma rises to the surface. This degassing process is less violent compared to the rapid, explosive release of gases in high-viscosity magmas. [cite relevant ScienceDirect article on gas content in basaltic magmas here, e.g., "Title of Article" by Author et al., Year].

4. Magma Source and Ascent: Shield volcanoes are typically fed by hot spot volcanism or divergent plate boundaries. This setting often involves relatively rapid and continuous magma supply from the mantle. The continuous flow of magma means the pressure build-up is less likely to reach explosive levels. [cite relevant ScienceDirect article on magma source and ascent in shield volcanoes here, e.g., "Title of Article" by Author et al., Year]. The magma often rises through fissures or cracks, further facilitating the release of gases and reducing pressure.

The Eruptive Processes: Effusive Dominance

The combination of low viscosity, low silica content, and the relatively gradual degassing leads to predominantly effusive eruptions. These eruptions are characterized by:

• Lava Flows: The low-viscosity lava flows relatively smoothly across the landscape, often spreading over vast areas. The distance the lava flows depends on factors such as lava temperature, slope, and volume.
• Lava Fountains: Sometimes, the release of gases can produce spectacular lava fountains, where molten lava is ejected into the air. However, even these fountains are generally less violent than the explosive pyroclastic flows seen in stratovolcanoes.
• Lava Lakes: In some cases, lava can pool in a crater or caldera, forming a lava lake – a mesmerizing but relatively benign phenomenon.

Exceptions and Nuances:

It's crucial to acknowledge that not all shield volcano eruptions are uniformly gentle. There can be variations in the eruptive style. Some factors that can influence the degree of explosivity include:

• Water interaction: If magma interacts with groundwater or surface water, it can lead to more explosive phreatomagmatic eruptions, even in basaltic systems. The rapid vaporization of water can generate significant pressure.
• Magma mixing: Mixing of different magma types can alter the viscosity and gas content, potentially leading to more explosive activity.
• Changes in magma supply rate: A sudden increase in magma supply rate can temporarily increase pressure and lead to more vigorous eruptions. [cite relevant ScienceDirect article on variations in shield volcano eruptive styles here, e.g., "Title of Article" by Author et al., Year].

Conclusion: A Gentle Giant's Secret

The relatively weak eruptions of shield volcanoes are primarily a consequence of the properties of their basaltic magma: low viscosity and low silica content allowing for easier gas escape. While effusive eruptions are the dominant style, variations can occur due to factors such as water interaction and magma mixing. Understanding these fundamental geological processes is vital not only for appreciating the beauty and grandeur of shield volcanoes but also for accurately assessing the associated volcanic hazards. Future research focusing on the precise mechanisms of degassing in basaltic magmas, and the dynamics of magma ascent, will further refine our understanding of these fascinating volcanic features. Continuous monitoring and detailed analysis of past eruptions, as documented extensively in ScienceDirect's vast database, are crucial for predicting future activity and mitigating potential risks.